Fishing from a kayak has become increasingly popular in recent years, as more and more anglers realize the many benefits of this approach. Kayaks are versatile, maneuverable, and allow fishermen to access remote areas that are inaccessible by traditional boats. However, when it comes to choosing a kayak for fishing, one of the most important decisions to make is whether to go for a sit-in or sit-on kayak. Both options have their own set of advantages and disadvantages, so it's important to weigh up the pros and cons before making a decision.
Sit-In Kayaks for Fishing
Sit-in kayaks are the traditional style of kayak that you sit inside, with your legs and lower body enclosed within the hull. Here are the pros and cons of using a sit-in kayak for fishing:
Pros:
-
Protection from the Elements - One of the most significant advantages of a sit-in kayak is that it provides protection from the elements. Because your lower body is enclosed within the kayak, you are less exposed to wind, rain, and waves, which can make for a more comfortable and enjoyable fishing experience.
-
Better for Cold Water - If you plan to do a lot of fishing in colder waters, a sit-in kayak is the way to go. Because of the enclosed design, you are less likely to get wet and therefore more likely to stay warm and comfortable.
-
Improved Stability - Sit-in kayaks have a lower center of gravity, which can make them more stable in rough conditions. This means that you are less likely to tip over when fishing in choppy waters, which can provide added peace of mind.
Cons:
-
Less Storage Space - Because sit-in kayaks are designed with an enclosed cockpit, they tend to have less storage space than sit-on kayaks. This means that you may need to be more selective about what gear you bring on your fishing trips.
-
Harder to Enter/Exit - One of the main drawbacks of sit-in kayaks is that they can be more challenging to enter and exit. Because your legs are enclosed within the kayak, it can be tricky to get in and out, especially if you are wearing bulky fishing gear.
-
Can Be More Expensive - Sit-in kayaks tend to be more expensive than sit-on kayaks, primarily due to the added features and materials required for the enclosed design.
Sit-On Kayaks for Fishing
Sit-on kayaks are a newer style of kayak that features an open cockpit, allowing you to sit on top of the kayak with your legs and lower body exposed. Here are the pros and cons of using a sit-on kayak for fishing:
Pros:
-
More Storage Space - Sit-on kayaks generally have more storage space than sit-in kayaks, which can be a big advantage when it comes to carrying fishing gear, tackle boxes, and other accessories.
-
Easy to Enter/Exit - With the open cockpit design, sit-on kayaks are generally easier to enter and exit than sit-in kayaks. This can be especially helpful when you are launching from a dock or beach.
-
More Affordable - Sit-on kayaks tend to be more affordable than sit-in kayaks, making them an attractive option for anglers on a budget.
Cons:
-
Exposed to the Elements - Because sit-on kayaks have an open cockpit, you are more exposed to the elements. This can make for a less comfortable fishing experience, especially in windy or rainy conditions.
-
Less Stability - Sit-on kayaks have a higher center of gravity, which can make them less stable in rough conditions. This means that you may be more likely to tip over when fishing in choppy waters.
-
Harder to Paddle - Because you are sitting on top of the kayak rather than inside, it can be more challenging to paddle